In my earlier blog post, “Is Clear Cooperation Helping or Hurting Sellers?”, I explored how the National Association of Realtors’ Clear Cooperation Policy (CCP) can both help and hinder sellers. As the real estate landscape continues to evolve, it's worth revisiting this topic — especially with fresh perspectives on how this policy impacts both buyers and sellers in 2024.
A Quick Look Back: What Is the Clear Cooperation Policy?
Introduced in 2020, the CCP requires properties to be listed on the MLS within one business day of public marketing unless the seller opts for an "Office Exclusive" exemption. The policy was designed to increase market transparency, ensuring more homes are publicly available for buyers to see and reducing the practice of so-called "pocket listings."
While this sounds great in theory, the reality is more complex. The question we continue to ask in 2024: Is the CCP striking the right balance between market fairness and seller freedom?
Sellers: Flexibility or Exposure — What’s the Right Call?
The pressure on sellers today is palpable. With fluctuating interest rates and cautious buyers, sellers need to weigh every tool at their disposal. Listing a property on the MLS can maximize visibility, potentially leading to multiple offers and a faster sale. Data from Bright MLS suggests that homes sold outside the MLS bring in 17.5% less, which is hard to ignore when every dollar counts.
Yet, there are still valid reasons for keeping a property off the public radar. Some sellers prefer privacy or want to test the waters with select buyers before committing to a full-scale listing. For high-end or unique properties, targeted marketing strategies can be more effective than mass exposure. The question becomes: Should the policy make room for more flexibility, especially when sellers' needs vary so widely?
Buyers: The CCP Ensures Broader Access
For buyers, the CCP offers a real advantage by guaranteeing that the majority of homes for sale are visible to everyone, not just a select few. In today’s competitive environment, missing out on hidden listings can mean losing the perfect property. By keeping listings in one place through the MLS, the process becomes simpler, making it easier to monitor available inventory without scouring multiple brokerage networks.
However, it’s important to recognize that not every buyer benefits equally from this policy. While the MLS promotes accessibility, buyers looking for exclusive, off-market opportunities might find CCP limiting. Investors or high-net-worth individuals often prefer to pursue properties quietly, avoiding the frenzy that can come with MLS exposure.
Fairness and Market Transparency: A Delicate Balance
The intention behind the CCP is to prevent unfair practices, such as limiting listings to certain buyer groups. This helps create a more inclusive market, ensuring that everyone — regardless of background — has access to the same opportunities. However, there are still challenges. As the debate around CCP continues, the real estate industry must remain open to adjustments that prioritize fairness without restricting seller options unnecessarily.
What’s Next for the CCP in 2024?
As the conversation around CCP evolves, there’s growing interest in potential reforms, such as extending the one-day rule or expanding exceptions for unique properties. These ideas could introduce greater flexibility while still maintaining the transparency the policy aims to achieve. Striking the right balance is key. Sellers need to feel empowered to choose the best strategy for their situation, and buyers need access to opportunities without facing unnecessary barriers.
Whether you’re a seller navigating a shifting market or a buyer searching for your dream home, the key takeaway is this: The best outcomes happen when transparency and strategy work hand in hand. The MLS will continue to play a vital role in keeping the market efficient, but ongoing discussions about CCP may bring much-needed refinements to better serve everyone involved.
—
For further details on market trends and to explore opportunities in Southwest Colorado, feel free to contact me. Let’s navigate these changing times together and find the best deals tailored to your needs.
Subscribe to our weekly newsletter for the latest market insights and trends!
